X/@screentime
First official promotional footage of Liam Hemsworth as Geralt of Rivia for The Witcher Season 4 had been launched on October 30, 2025. The Australian lifer takes over the enduring function from Henry Cavill, who, after Season 3, left the present due to disagreements over learn how to method the present in relation to its supply materials. The discharge was a catalyst for a livid on-line debate in regards to the recasting and the way forward for the fantasy sequence.
Commercial
Effectively, to be frank, Cavill was nearly an inconceivable act to comply with. The person didn’t simply play the character; he grew to become the character. So when the first-look footage of Hemsworth sporting a white wig and armor had been launched, the web couldn’t shut up. All kinds of ideas had been being put out!
On full armor, with the acquainted white hair and yellow cat eye, he appears to be the Geralt of Liam Hemsworth. However the vibe… is a little bit totally different. “He doesn’t even have the aura” an individual instantly stated, mainly the sentiment spreading round. It’s not that Hemsworth appears dangerous. It’s that he doesn’t seem like the Geralt everyone has fallen in love with by way of three seasons.
Then got here easy feedback: “Seems like an SNL parody lmao.” Ouch! However truthfully? Coming from that comparability, it could possibly be one of many extra merciful ones. One other one stated he regarded like “Invoice and Ted Geralt,” which once more is painfully hilarious and painfully correct trying on the first look footage.
So even the costume selections appear to have raised some eyebrows. One replied, “What’s that match? Doesn’t even seem like a witcher,” whereas one other adopted with, “they turned bro right into a biker with a shitty haircut man FUCK.” The wardrobe division actually ought to stay a time restrict on their intern expertise.
However actually? One isn’t the purpose. “Nothing in opposition to Liam, I actually don’t know his appearing capacity in any respect, however they tremendous set him up by making him seem like somebody making an attempt to seem like Henry.” That’s the place the unspeakable component lies. The showrunners now ask the viewers to just accept the notion of a brand new actor for an outdated character whereas wanting all the things else to remain the identical.
The exact same inventive variations that pitched Cavillor lastly out step into this dialogue. A fan voiced what everyone’s pondering: “Henry Cavill was proper, he doesn’t comply with the books anymore, I don’t even perceive why there’s a season 4 and 5, They need to have stopped at season 3 when he left!!!”
Actual concern is expressed for the survival of the sequence by way of this transition: “This present will now free its viewers with Henry gone & Netflix transferring away from authentic storyline I see an abrupt cancellation of the sequence sooner,” speculated one other, “Altering main character in a film makes me lose curiosity…😔.”
Nevertheless, not everyone seems to be all doom and gloom about this. Some stay hopeful. “Misplaced all aura however perhaps the appearing will impress,” one remark learn. “Sadly, he’s simply not that man 🥲. Will nonetheless watch tho,” stated one other. In all probability the most typical place – uncertain but prepared to provide it a shot.
After all, the comparability sport is inevitable, and for the brand new man, it’s clearly not sounding good. One typical remark learn, “Henry Is the 🐐i miss him,” with a crying emoji. One other stated, “I like liam hemsworth however Henry is the og and can stay the og.”
Some followers have very logical ideas about how the present may have dealt with the transition higher: “Ought to’ve simply killed off geralt. I imply they killed eskel like he was nothing. Make liam a model new witcher or Lambert.” And that’s actually good — bringing in one of many new witchers might need felt much less sinking to audiences than making an attempt to place away Cavill.
The extra main subject behind this transition is that the majority followers assume the sequence was dropping in high quality nicely earlier than all of the recasting drama began. “Truthfully the present wasn’t good within the first place lol,” admitted one, whereas one other declared, “This present is SO dangerous now. Final season was straight rubbish.”
A way of it’s only one massive missed alternative hangs within the air. One fan painted an alternate model: “Think about that in some universe nearly similar to ours, HBO acquired the rights to adapt The Witcher and the sequence was extra profitable than Sport of Thrones.” Ouch. Now, the Netflix prime canine have to be hurting in studying the response to this.
Maybe probably the most balanced take is from somebody who stated: “Nonetheless the identical writers. Nonetheless the identical runners that thought we had been craving for blood origins and rats.” The take is that Hemsworth is carrying the again finish of all the problems the sequence has, not simply Cavill’s sneakers.
Commercial
Pay attention, making an attempt to recast any main function is at all times harmful. Bear in mind when Don Cheadle stepped in for Terrence Howard in Iron Man? You would nearly say it labored out. However making an attempt to snapshot mainly a wholly new lead actor three seasons in of an adored sequence? There’s by no means been something fairly like that. The look into pictures appears to counsel that proper from the get-go, this sequence is capturing to slip units of trainers from underneath Cavill whereas concurrently altering what’s beneath. Whether or not viewers go on to just accept this new Geralt or not, that’s nonetheless to be seen come subsequent October. The White Wolf does have some very giant sneakers to fill, and, judging by preliminary responses, will probably be a tall order certainly.