Slasher movies got here of age within the Reagan period.
So it’s becoming that filmmakers take Doc Brown’s DeLorean again to the ’80s to inform new tales.
“Evening of the Reaper” does simply that, including a VHS twist alongside the way in which. It’s sensible and satisfying with a killer opening sequence, however like some fashionable movies, it doesn’t know when to say, “sufficient.”
A younger and spunky babysitter named Emily (Summer season Howell) resides her greatest life, dancing to Pat Benatar and sneaking a cigarette break on the job.
What occurs subsequent is each predictable and chilling. Few current horror movies have opened higher. It’s nearly price watching the entire movie only for this sequence.
Co-writer/director Brandon Christensen instantly has our consideration.
The motion strikes on to Emily’s sister, Deena (Jessica Clement), a sullen school scholar returning to her hometown. Deena reconnects with outdated family and friends. She additionally snags a babysitting gig when her buddy will get sick.
The kid in query is the son of Sheriff Rod (Ryan Robbins), nonetheless haunted by his spouse’s passing.
Demise is just too frequent on this cozy hamlet, and issues are about to get a lot worse.
Everybody dances with the reaper.
NIGHT OF THE REAPER is streaming now on Shudder. pic.twitter.com/xPbl9DUKzz
— Shudder (@Shudder) September 19, 2025
Christensen (“The Puppetman”) doesn’t overdo the ’80s shout-outs, however the movie isn’t as clear-eyed as wanted. One late-movie demise can have quite a lot of viewers members scratching their heads.
Dueling storylines observe each Deena’s more and more scary babysitting gig and Sheriff Rodney’s investigation, fueled by creepy VHS tapes. Christensen’s management on the narrative isn’t as tight as wanted.
In any other case, he marshals old-school horror tropes – creaking doorways, chilling silences – in a crisp, environment friendly method.
The story pays eager consideration to the primary characters, giving them time to breathe and join with us on a real degree. Younger Clement proves notably adept at conveying a world-weary teen with out seeming clichéd.
The sheriff’s rising rage presents one other fascinating component, leavened by an workplace flirtation and inter-office politics. This “Reaper” pays consideration to smaller particulars, and the outcomes are wealthy and rewarding.
To some extent.
Tone, pacing and environment are all higher than anticipated, and we’re desperate to see the place issues could lead. The third act offers the solutions, but it surely’s clearly a case of a too-smart-by-half script that stumbles slightly than soars.
Third acts are routinely difficult for horror administrators. It’s one purpose the current “Weapons” proved so satisfying. Nonetheless, even with the misdirection in play, “Evening of the Reaper” is a minimize above most indie shockers.
NOTE: “Evening of the Reaper” is enjoying on AMC+ and Shudder
HiT or Miss: “Evening of the Reaper” begins sturdy and proves slasher movies don’t should be brain-dead affairs.