James Cameron is a genius.
If we didn’t understand it after “Aliens” (1986), “Terminator: Judgment Day” (1991) and “Titanic” (1997), it’s clear after a trio of “Avatar” movies.
Geniuses, alas, aren’t good.
Cameron’s eco-saga provides so many flaws that it’s onerous to course of them in a single sitting. Visually magnificent and narratively sloppy, the saga reveals no indicators of enchancment by way of “Avatar: Hearth and Ash.”
It’s a multitude. But you may’t look away, and Cameron’s refusal to surrender on 3D could also be its key promoting level.
We choose up the saga shortly after the occasions of “Avatar: The Approach of Water.” The Sully clan continues to be mourning the lack of Neteyam (Jamie Flatters), the household’s oldest son. The clan seems at peace all the identical, however the evil/depraved/monstrous Colonel Quaritch (the nice Stephen Lang) hasn’t given up the combat.
He’s nonetheless hell bent on taking on Pandora and organising store to make thousands and thousands. That Navy Industrial Complicated doesn’t occur by itself, ya know.
This time, the Colonel groups with the chief of a fractured tribe referred to as the Ash individuals, led by Varang (Oona Chaplin). She’s a power of nature, crafty and misleading.
Man, these ones and zeroes could make film magic.
Collectively, they pose an much more harmful risk to the Na’vi, and it’ll take the planet’s peace-loving members to discover a technique to thwart their newest assault.
If this all sounds acquainted, it ought to.
RELATED: KARMA COMES FOR JAMES CAMERON’S ‘AVATAR’ SAGA
The weather trotted out right here replicate among the final movie’s story. And, to a lesser extent, “Avatar.” It’s not unusual for a franchise to repeat key components, however at three hours and 15-odd minutes that repetition is, properly, unconscionable.
Why would an artist like Cameron primarily copy himself, spending countless {dollars} within the course of? His mission with the “Avatar” saga is to make audiences rethink their connection to Mom Earth.
That’s simplistic and noble, however his movies are more and more indifferent from that messaging. “Hearth and Ash” isn’t as heavy-handed as earlier than, however principally as a result of the lectures really feel acquainted at this level.
They didn’t transfer the popular culture needle the primary time. There’s little likelihood that may change with Chapter 3.
What’s maddening this time round is the Quaritch/Jake Sully (Sam Worthington) pressure. These mortal enemies squabble and combat, but it surely appears perfunctory at this level. At one key second, they lay down their theoretical arms, as if Cameron himself isn’t certain why they’re nonetheless at one another’s throats.
This saga is exhausted, and even Cameron senses it.
The brand new movie is as soon as once more overstuffed with characters, subplots and visible marvels, to the purpose the place it deadens our senses. The primary 10 minutes have us staring on the display screen, our mouths agape at what Cameron and co. cooked up for our pleasure.
Digital trickery feels routine at this level. Not if you’re witnessing an “Avatar” spectacle.
That sense of marvel doesn’t final. Sooner or later, we’d like compelling characters and a narrative that calls for our consideration. What we get are two marvelous villains, a crush of character beats that alternately impress and underwhelm and little sense of storytelling momentum.
The place is that this all going? To the large battle, in fact, identical to within the first two movies. If that’s a spoiler … then you definitely don’t acknowledge franchise storytelling on autopilot.
After which there’s the dialogue. Some characters provide glib takes on life and native tradition, a sop to spirituality and eco-worship. Take it or depart it, however “Hearth and Ash” has a viewpoint and boasts a constant method right here.
However Cameron, who co-wrote the script with Rick Jaffa and Amanda Silver, can’t assist ladling out twenty first century colloquialisms which take us out of the story. Many times.
Assume Christopher Reeve seeing that shiny brown penny in “Someplace in Time.”
Isn’t there anybody on the crew who can faucet them on the shoulder and say, “Possibly this type of corny banter is beneath your imaginative and prescient?” After which, in fact, duck, as a result of that may not finish properly for the one who says it.
Cameron’s genius infects each body of “Avatar: Hearth and Ash.” His incapability to see his personal flaws does, too.
Hit or Miss: “Avatar: Hearth and Ash” introduces us to new villains, previous buddies we barely cared about within the first place and a narrative that’s each exhausting and acquainted.